Colchester, Connecticut

Enrollment Projection until 2030 11052020

Board of Education Meeting 6:00PM

← Document Library

enrollment / staffing FY 2020-21 BoardDocs (BOE meetings) 2020-11-10

Machine-extracted text of a publicly posted document, provided for reference and search. The original document at the link above is authoritative.

COLCHESTER PUBLIC SCHOOLS
ENROLLMENT PROJECTED TO 2030




           Peter M. Prowda, PhD
             28 Old Mill Court
            Simsbury, CT 06070
               (860) 658-9919
          peteprowda@yahoo.com

            November 5, 2020
                                          Table of Contents

Section                                                       Page

Introduction                                                    1

Perspective                                                     1

Current Enrollment                                              2

Projection Method                                               3

Total Enrollment                                                5

Colchester Elementary School Enrollment                         6

Jack Jackter School Enrollment                                  7

William J. Johnson Middle School Enrollment                     8

Bacon Academy Enrollment                                        9

Factors Affecting the Projection                               10

Context of the Projection                                      13

Prior Projections of Enrollment                                17

Summary                                                        18

Appendices                                                     19

List of Tables

 1. 2020 Enrollment                                             2
 2. Total Enrollment                                            5
 3. Colchester Elementary School Enrollment                     6
 4. Jack Jackter School Enrollment                              7
 5. William J. Johnson Middle School Enrollment                 8
 6. Bacon Academy Enrollment                                    9
 7. Analysis of Kindergarten Enrollment                        11




                                                  2
List of Figures                                                                        Page

 1. Colchester Enrollment 1970 to Date                                                   2
 2. Schools Attended by Town Residents, 2020                                             2
 3. Resident and Open Choice Enrollment by Grade, 2020                                   3
 4. Total Enrollment                                                                     5
 5. Colchester Elementary School Enrollment                                              6
 6. Jack Jackter School Enrollment                                                       7
 7. William J. Johnson Middle School Enrollment                                          8
 8. Bacon Academy Enrollment                                                             9
 9. Births since 1980                                                                   10
10. Kindergarten Yield from Birth Cohort                                                10
11. Grade to Grade Growth Rates                                                         11
12. Town Population Growth 2010 to 2019                                                 13
13. Projected Colchester Population Ages 0-19                                           13
14. Colchester Women of Child-Bearing Age                                               14
15. Recent Changes in the Labor Force                                                   14
16. Net New Housing Units                                                               14
17. Sales of Existing Single-Family Homes and Condominiums                              15
18. Annual High School Dropout Rate                                                     15
19. Non-Public School Enrollment                                                        15
20. Residents Enrolled in Other Public Schools                                          16
21. Tuition Students attending Bacon Academy                                            16
23. Estimated Student Migration                                                         16
24. Prior Projections of Enrollment                                                     17


List of Appendices

A. Colchester Enrollment Projected by Grade to 2030: Primary and Intermediate Grades    19
B. Colchester Enrollment Projected by Grade to 2030: Middle and High School Grades      20




                                                 3
Introduction

This report presents a ten-year projection of enrollment for the Colchester Public Schools. It is based on
students enrolled in Colchester schools, a PK-2, 3-5, 6-8 and 9-12 grade alignment. The report includes
51 years of enrollment to place the projection into a wider historical perspective. One of the primary
drivers of future enrollment is births to residents. The report examines births and their relationship to
kindergarten enrollment. Several factors that influence school enrollment - town population, women of
child-bearing age, employment, housing, high school dropouts, non-public enrollment, resident
enrollment in other public schools, non-resident enrollment in Colchester schools and migration - are
presented. Finally, the accuracy of earlier projections is examined.

Enrollment projections are a valuable planning tool. For budgeting, the numbers can place requested
expenditures into a per pupil context. This can inform the public about which expenditures represent
continuing expenditures to support on-going programs and expenditures for school improvement and
program expansion. They are an essential step in determining the staffing that will be needed in the
future. This may facilitate the transfer of teachers from one grade to another or allow the hiring process to
start earlier, which can increase the likelihood of attracting the best teachers in the marketplace.
Projections are a critical and required step in planning for school facilities. The State of Connecticut
requires eight-year school-based projections as a critical component of determining the size of the project
for which reimbursement is eligible. This report is appropriate for that purpose for all of your schools. In
some communities the projection can determine the number of places they can make available to urban
students as part of a regional desegregation effort.

This projection was run during the Covid-19 epidemic which has had profound fiscal and physical
implications. If fiscal issues dominate, we might expect students to return from private schools and a
decline in births in 2021 and 2022. If physical (social distance) issues dominate, we might expect fewer
children riding buses to magnet schools, more families deciding to home-school their children, or more
families choosing private schools with smaller class sizes. My initial take is that these factors seem to
have had a greater negative impact on elementary enrollment. A key assumption behind the method used
in this report is that enrollment patterns in the near future will be reflected in the patterns of the recent
past. I assume that the pandemic will be substantially behind us by the fall of 2021. I have made what I
believe are the best possible adjustments to this unique situation.

Perspective

Enrollment projections typically use the most recent five years of data. While the most recent past is
viewed as the best predictor of the near future, it is informative to look at a broader perspective. Figure 1
shows the enrollment in Colchester from 1970 to date.

Enrollment in the Colchester Public Schools grew from 1,828 students in 1970 to 1,906 students in 1975.
Between then and 1981, enrollment went on a brief decline that took it to 1,483 students. In those six
years, enrollment declined by 423 students or 22.2 percent. Between 1981 and 2006 enrollment increased
by 1,759 students. The 3,242 students enrolled in 2006 was the all-time peak and represented a huge 119
percent increase over the 1981 low. Enrollment then entered a second downward cycle. Between 2006
and 2020 enrollment declined by 1,046 students or 32.3 percent. The 2020 enrollment of 2,196 students
is similar to that of 1994.

Colchester's enrollment pattern is only roughly similar to that of the state's public schools. Between its
1971 peak and 1988, Connecticut public school enrollment declined by 31.5 percent. State enrollment hit
a secondary peak in 2004. It grew 24.5 percent between the 1988 low and 2004. State enrollment
declined by a projected 13.0 percent between 2004 and 2020. The 1970 to 1975 growth in Colchester was
steeper that the state's. The subsequent enrollment decline in Colchester was much shorter in length than
the state's and less deep. Colchester’s 1981 to 2006 growth period was much longer than the state’s and

                                                      4
very much greater in magnitude. Colchester's second cycle of decline has been shorter than the state's but
more severe. Had ColchesterFigure  1. Colchester
                              followed               Enrollment
                                       the state pattern            1970it3to
                                                         of enrollment,     3 3Date
                                                                            would3 have had only 1,366
                                                                3  33332223 33
students enrolled in October of 2020 instead of your enrollment2 1of 2,196.
                                                                     1 1 1     1 2
                                                                                   0 2
                   3500                                                   2 0 55624380 0 2
                                                                       228910                 7 8 2
                                                                              9 8 4 9 2 8 0 4 8 1 8 7 6 2 2,2,
                                                                     2660092                    7 3 5
                   3000                                            2424 0
                                                                          4                       0 3 4 4 2,2,2,
                                                                 22     9                           3 57333
                                  1                            110 10                                 81           1
                          1 1 1 1   1                        1 9   6                                      28119
                   2500 1 8 8 8 8 9 8 1 1              1 1 1   9 9
                                                                     8
                                                                                                               1 2
                        8             7 11 11111 67836 2
      Enrollment



                                                                                                                   6
                        266890676651               5 6 6     3 45
                   2000 8 9 9 5 8 6     8  4 5 4 5       9 0   5
                                    65 0             05      0
                                        913819147727
                                          235782
                   1500

                   1000

                   500

                   0
                         70
                         72
                         74
                         76
                         78
                         80
                         82
                         84
                         86
                         88
                         90
                         92
                         94
                         96
                         98
                         00
                         02
                         04
                         06
                         08
                         10
                         12
                         14
                         16
                         18
                         20
                                                               October of Year

                                                      Colchester         State Pattern


Current Enrollment

Table 1 and Figure 2 provide a picture of where Colchester residents attended school on October 1, 2020.
The data, provided by the Colchester Central Office, should be considered preliminary. The non-public
data were projected. They show that 89.4 percent of Colchester's school-age residents attended the
Colchester Public Schools in October of 2020. A projected 75 school-age residents (3.1 percent) attended
non-public schools in state. The number attending private schools out-of-state is not known. This figure
includes nine students paid by the district to attend a non-public special education program.


 Table 1. 2020 Enrollment
                                      Numbe      Percen
                                          r           t
 Residents
                                                                             Figure 2. Schools Attended by Town
  A. Colchester Public                  2,171     89.4%
                                                                                        Residents, 2020
  B. Magnet                                42      1.7%                      Tech+ Other Non- Home-
                                                                       Magnet Ag Public,Public,School
  C. Tech.+ Ag. Sci.                       60      2.5%                 ,2% Sci,2% 1% 3% ed,2%
  D. Other Public                          32      1.3%
  E. Non-Public                            75      3.1%
  F. Home-Schooled                         49      2.0%
 Total (A+B+C+D+E)                      2,429
   G. Non-Residents                        25                                            Town
 Total Enrollment                                                                        Public,
 (A+G)                                  2,196                                             89%




                                                                   5
Forty-two school-age residents attended charter or magnet schools (1.7 percent). Sixty students attended
a state technical high school or an agriculture science program (2.5 percent). Thirty-two students (1.3
percent) attended another public school, most in a special education program run by a Regional Service
Center. There were 25 non-residents who attended Bacon Academy on a tuition basis in 2020. The
projections in this report are based upon the 2,196 residents and non-residents who attend the Colchester
Public Schools on October 1, 2020 (See “Total Enrollment” on the prior page).

Figure 3 shows the October 1, 2020 enrollment by grade of Colchester and Norwich students in the
Colchester Public Schools. The children in pre-kindergarten programs are not shown. Grade 10 had the
largest enrollment with 197 students. Grades 9, 11 and 12 had at least 175 students enrolled. Grade 2
was the smallest class with only 130 students. Grade 4 had 139 students enrolled and grade 1 had 153.
Without a solid in-migration or an increase in births, this pattern usually results in a future enrollment
decline. If current conditions continue, this year's kindergarten class of 147 students could have 158
students when it enters grade 3 at the Jack Jackter School in 2023, 154 students when it enters grade 6 at
the William J. Johnson Middle School in 2026 and 160 students when it enters grade 9 at Bacon Academy
in 2029. All except grade 3 are below the current enrollment in those grades. The current year
enrollment by grade is the starting point for this projection. How it moves forward is discussed below.



                                     Figure 3. Enrollment By Grade, 2020


                   250


                   200                                                                 197
                                                                                             184   187
                                                                     170   169   175
                                           159                165
                         147
      Enrollment




                   150         143               139   145
                                     130

                   100


                   50


                   0
                         K     1     2     3     4     5       6     7     8     9     10    11    12

                                                             Grade



Projection Method

The projections in this report were generated primarily using the cohort survival method. This is the
standard method used by people running enrollment projections. For the grades above kindergarten, I
compute grade-to-grade growth rates for ten years (see Appendices A and B). For example, if the number
of fourth graders this year is 143 and the number of third graders last year was 140, then the growth rate is
1.021. Growth rates above 1.000 indicate that students moved in, transferred from non-public schools or
other public schools or were retained. Growth rates below 1.000 mean that students moved out,
transferred to private or other public schools, dropped out, or were not promoted from the prior grade.
For each grade I calculated five different averages of the year-to-year growth rates: a three-year average;
a weighted three-year average; a four-year average from 2016 to 2019; a five-year average and a weighted
                                                        6
five-year average. I choose the average that seems to best fit the data. The average growth rate for a
grade is applied to the prior year’s enrollment from the prior grade. The projection builds grade by grade
and year by year.

The growth rates used in the projection were based on four-year averages (from 2016 to 2019) of the
observed grade-to-grade growth. This eliminates the negative impact of Covid-19 on enrollment in 2020.
This was the highest of the four averages calculated. In kindergarten I used the four-year averages (from
2016 to 2019). In grade 9, I adjusted the annual growth rates in 2015 to 2020 to reflect residents only. I
then assumed 9 students (the average over the past three years) from Norwich would enroll in grade 9 in
2020 and annually thereafter. I adjusted enrollment in grades 10-12 based on the four-year average
attrition.

I broke kindergarten into five-year olds, six-year olds entering kindergarten for the first time and
repeaters. With births returning to more normal levels, I used a four-year average (2016-2019) of each
component for all the years of the projection. I projected pre-kindergarten enrollment from the four-year
average (2016-2019) of the ratio of prekindergarten enrollment one year with the average of births three-
and four-years ago.

The number of children home-schooled jumped from 15 in 2019 to 49 in 2020. I assumed that increase
was due to parents’ concerns about Covid-19. I have assumed in this report that the impact of Covid-19
will be substantially behind us by October, 2021. Accordingly, I assumed that 50 percent of the students
home-schooled in 2020 would return to the Colchester Public Schools in 2021 and that 50 percent of the
balance would return in 2022. That model would return the number home-schooled to about 15 students
in 2023.

To extend the projections beyond four years, I needed to estimate births for the years 2020 to 2025. The
Connecticut State Department of Public Health recorded 144 births to Colchester residents in 2017. That
is the latest official count. The provisional counts were 135 in 2018 and 159 in 2019. These rarely
change. I estimated there would be 138 births in 2020 from the number of in-state births through
September of 2020, expected number of in-state births from October to December based on the ratio of
October to December births versus January to September births over the past five years and the average
out-of-state births in 2018 and 2019. I used the Connecticut State Data Center’s 2017 projections of
women of child-bearing ages in 2020 and 2025 along with my estimate of the 2018 fertility rate for
Colchester to estimate births in 2020 and 2025. I calculated annual growth rates for 2020 to 2025 and
applied them to the moving three-year averages of births starting in 2018 and 2020 to estimate births
through 2025. I adjusted births downward by three percent in 2021 and 2022 based on the change in the
August unemployment rates in 2010 and 2020. Research has shown decreased birth rates after periods of
increased unemployment and employment insecurity. That resulted in an average of 146 births annually
in the 2021 to 2025 period.

Enrollment data from 2010 to 2019 were taken from files provided by the Connecticut State Department of
Education. Note that current district-level data on the Department's website may include special education
students educated outside of the district and exclude students in a Detention Center. These are recent changes
to the way the Department reports enrollment data. Projections require consistency. The data I have chosen
for this analysis exclude special education students educated outside of the district and may include students
in a Detention Center. Enrollment data can change daily until an audited final file is closed. This process can
take up to two years. Thus, it is possible that the enrollment data in this report could differ slightly from data
in earlier reports and that may have been reported by your Board of Education to the public. The Colchester
central office provided enrollments in 2020. Births from 1980 to 2020 were provided by the Healthcare
Quality, Statistics, Analysis and Reporting Unit of the State Department of Public Health.




                                                      7
Total Enrollment

Table 2 and Figure 4 present the observed total enrollment in                            Table 2. Total Enrollment
Colchester schools from 2010 to 2020 and projected enrollment
through 2030. Detailed grade-by-grade data may be found in                                                         Percent
Appendices A and B. Total enrollment in Colchester fell from 3,078                       Year         Students     Change
students in 2010 to 2,196 students in in 2020. Enrollment                                2010          3,078
plummeted by 882 students or 28.7 percent between 2010 and 2020.                         2011          3,017            -2.0%
I project that public-school enrollment statewide will have declined                     2012          2,880            -4.5%
7.4 percent in that period.                                                              2013          2,733            -5.1%
                                                                                         2014          2,638            -3.5%
                                                                                         2015          2,551            -3.3%
Between 2009 and 2019, the latest data available, the enrollment loss
                                                                                         2016          2,426            -4.9%
of 27.9 percent in Colchester was in the largest among similar (DRG                      2017          2,438             0.5%
D) towns in the area. Rocky Hill gained 2.2 percent. The losses in                       2018          2,311            -5.2%
Cromwell (-3.9 percent), Wethersfield (-6.1 percent), East Hampton                       2019          2,312             0.0%
(-9.3 percent), Newington (-10.6 percent), East Lyme (-13.2 percent),                    2020          2,196            -5.0%
Berlin (-13.4 percent), Clinton (-17.0 percent) and Old Saybrook                         2021          2,190            -0.3%
(-25.1 percent) were all smaller than Colchester’s loss.                                 2022          2,166            -1.1%
                                                                                         2023          2,125            -1.9%
I project that the enrollment decline will continue through 2023 and                     2024          2,130             0.2%
then recover. Next year, I anticipate that total enrollment will                         2025          2,131             0.0%
                                                                                         2026          2,135             0.2%
decrease by 5-10 students. I anticipate that the enrollment low will
                                                                                         2027          2,135             0.0%
come in 2023 at about 2,125 students. By the year 2030, enrollment                       2028          2,155             0.9%
could approach 2,200 students. That would be essentially unchanged                       2029          2,184             1.3%
from the October 2020 count. In the state's public schools, I am                         2030          2,199             0.7%
projecting an 8.7 percent decline between 2020 and 2030. Total
enrollment in Colchester could average close to 2,155 students over the ten-year projection period
compared to an average total enrollment of 2,550 students over the past ten years.


                                                 Figure 4. Total Enrollment


                 3,500 3,07
                              3,01
                         8     7 2,88 2,73
                 3,000             0       2,63 2,55
                                       3
                                            8 1 2,42 2,43
                                                          2,31 2,31
                 2,500                               6 8                                                         2,19
                                                           1 2 2,19 2,19 2,16 2,12 2,13 2,13 2,13 2,13 2,15 2,18
                                                                    6 0   6 5 0 1 5 5 5 4 9
    Enrollment




                 2,000

                 1,500

                 1,000

                 500

                 0
                         10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
                                                  October of Year
                                                  Actual   Projected




                                                                   8
Colchester Elementary School Enrollment

Table 3 and Figure 5 present actual enrollment at the Colchester                                         Table 3. Colchester
Elementary School in 2010 to 2020 and projected enrollment to 2030.                                      Elementary School
Enrollment by grade may be found in Appendix A. Enrollment in                                            Enrollment
grades PK-2 declined from 698 students in 2010 to 503 students in
2016 and then rebounded to 555 students in 2019. There were losses                                                            Percent
of ten percent or more in 2012, 2013 and 2016. The 2020 enrollment                                       Year      Student    Change
                                                                                                         2010      s
                                                                                                                   698
dropped to 506 students. The 10-year loss of 192 students represented
                                                                                                         2011        680         -2.6%
27.5 percent of the enrollment in 2010. I project that public-school                                     2012        612       -10.0%
enrollment statewide in grades K-2 will have declined 11.3 percent in                                    2013        551       -10.0%
that period.                                                                                             2014        542         -1.6%
                                                                                                         2015        570          5.2%
If a typical kindergarten class emerged from the unusually large                                         2016        503       -11.8%
number of births in 2016 and a portion of the students who are being                                     2017        543          8.0%
home-schooled during the Covid-19 epidemic return, then next year’s                                      2018        533         -1.8%
enrollment could reach 570 students, a 12.8 percent increase over this                                   2019        555          4.1%
year. By 2030, PK-2 enrollment at the Colchester Elementary School                                       2020      506        -8.8%
                                                                                                         2021      571        12.8%
could be close to 600 students. This would be similar to the number
                                                                                                         2022        595          4.2%
enrolled in 2012. This would be about 100 students more than 2020, a                                     2023        597          0.3%
gain of about 19 percent. In grades K-2 in the state's public schools, I                                 2024        591         -1.0%
am projecting a 6.0 percent enrollment decline. Over the ten-year                                        2025        586         -0.8%
projection period, I believe enrollment in grades PK-2 could average                                     2026        595          1.5%
about 590 students compared to the average of 560 students observed                                      2027        582         -2.2%
over the past ten years.                                                                                 2028        589          1.2%
                                                                                                         2029        598          1.5%
These figures include the children in your pre-kindergarten program.                                     2030      604        1.0%
Program enrollment ranged from 53 children in 2016 to 104 children in 2019. There were 86 children
enrolled in 2020. My projection model, based on births three- and four-years ago, projects pre-kindergarten
enrollment could range from 95 to 101 students over the next ten years.


                                    Figure 5. Colchester Elementary School Enrollment

                         800
                               698 680
                         700
                                         612                                                 595 597 591 586 595 582 589 598 604
                         600                   551 542 570                             571
                                                                   543 533 555
                                                             503                 506
                         500
       PK-2 Enrollment




                         400

                         300

                         200

                         100

                         0
                                10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
                                                                       October of Year
                                                                       Actual   Projected



                                                                          9
Jack Jackter School Enrollment

Table 4 and Figure 6 present actual enrollment at the Jack Jackter                                    Table 4. Jack Jackter
School from 2010 to 2020 and projected enrollment to 2030.                                            School Enrollment
Enrollment by grade may be found in Appendix A. Enrollment at the
school fell irregularly from 688 students in 2010 to 443 students in                                  Year     Student     Change
2020. There were declines of greater than five percent in 2015, 2016,                                 2010     s
                                                                                                               688
2018 and 2019. Between 2010 and 2020 enrollment declined by 245                                       2011       654          -4.9%
                                                                                                      2012       630          -3.7%
students or 35.6 percent. I project that enrollment in grades 3-5 will
                                                                                                      2013       614          -2.5%
have declined 9.7 percent in that period in the state's public schools.                               2014       585          -4.7%
                                                                                                      2015       531          -9.2%
I believe that future enrollment in grades 3-5 at the Jack Jackter                                    2016       498          -6.2%
School will drift downward and then recover. I expect an enrollment                                   2017       513           3.0%
low of close to 430 students in 2021. I expect enrollment could once                                  2018       482          -6.0%
again exceed 500 students in 2025 and remain near or at that level                                    2019       456          -5.4%
through 2030. I project the 2030 enrollment could be about 495                                        2020     443         -2.9%
students. That would be roughly the level in 2018. Over the ten-years                                 2021     432         -2.5%
from 2020 to 2030, I project a net increase of about 50 students or                                   2022       445           3.0%
                                                                                                      2023       443          -0.4%
between 11 and 12 percent. Over the ten-year projection period, I
                                                                                                      2024       491         10.8%
believe enrollment in grades 3-5 could average about 485 students                                     2025       508           3.5%
compared to the average of 541 students observed over the past ten                                    2026       509           0.2%
years. In the state's public schools, I project that enrollment in grades                             2027       508          -0.2%
3-5 will decline by 11.6 percent between 2020 and 2030.                                               2028       501          -1.4%
                                                                                                      2029       507           1.2%
                                                                                                      2030     494         -2.6%



                                          Figure 6. Jack Jackter School Enrollment


                        800

                        700 688 654
                                      630 614
                        600                     585
                                                      531
                                                            498 513 482                           491 508 509 508 501 507 494
       3-5 Enrollment




                        500                                               456 443
                                                                                    432 445 443
                        400

                        300

                        200

                        100

                        0
                              10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
                                                                    OctoberProjected
                                                                   Actual   of Year




                                                                          10
William J. Johnson Middle School Enrollment

Table 5 and Figure 7 present actual enrollment in grades 6-8 in 2010                                     Table 5. William J. Johnson    to
2020 and projected enrollment at the William J. Johnson Middle                                           Middle School Enrollment
School to 2030. Enrollment by grade may be found in Appendix B.                                                   Grades
The school’s enrollment fell from 705 students in 2010 to 504 in                                         Year     6-8        Change
2020. That was a loss of 201 students or 28.5 percent. The last time                                     2010     705
enrollment in these grades was near that level was 1994. I project that                                  2011       700         -0.7%
public-school enrollment in Connecticut will have fallen 6.3 percent in                                  2012       701          0.1%
those grades in those 10 years.                                                                          2013       668         -4.7%
                                                                                                         2014       625         -6.4%
                                                                                                         2015       600         -4.0%
I expect that enrollment at the William J. Johnson Middle School will
                                                                                                         2016       605          0.8%
drift irregularly downward for the next four years and then recover.                                     2017       571         -5.6%
All the students who will attend these grades over the next ten years                                    2018       520         -8.9%
school have already been born. Next year I anticipate that enrollment                                    2019       517         -0.6%   in
grades 6-8 will decline by about 20 students. I expect the enrollment                                    2020     504        -2.5%
low will come in 2024 at about 430 students. Pushed, in part, by a                                       2021     485        -3.8%
large increase in 2027, I believe enrollment could be close to 505                                       2022       457         -5.8%
students at the projection’s end. Over the ten-years, I project a zero                                   2023       445         -2.6%
net-gain. Over the ten-year projection period, I believe enrollment in                                   2024       431         -3.1%
grades 6-8 at the Middle School will average about 470 students                                          2025       441          2.3%
                                                                                                         2026       440         -0.2%
compared to the average of 601 students in grades 6-8 observed over
                                                                                                         2027       487         10.7%
the past ten years. In the state's public schools, I project that                                        2028       504          3.5%
enrollment in grades 6-8 will decline by11.0 percent in the next ten                                     2029       505          0.2%
years.                                                                                                   2030     504        -0.2%



                                Figure 7. William J. Johnson Middle School Enrollment


                      800
                            705 700 701
                      700                 668
                                                625
                                                      600 605
                      600                                       571
                                                                      520 517 504
                                                                                                                  487 504 505 504
     6-8 Enrollment




                      500                                                           485
                                                                                          457 445
                                                                                                    431 441 440
                      400

                      300

                      200

                      100

                      0
                             10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30

                                                                      October ofProjected
                                                                      Actual     Year




                                                                           11
Bacon Academy Enrollment

Grade 9 is the first opportunity to attend state technical high schools                           Table 6. Bacon Academy             and
agriculture science and technology centers. Preliminary October 2020                              Enrollment
data show that 83.8 percent of Colchester residents enrolled in grade 9
were enrolled in the district. I project 10 students (4.3 percent) will                                                    Percent
                                                                                                  Year       Student       Change
have enrolled in non-public schools in state. Sixteen 9th graders (7.1                            2010       s
                                                                                                             987
percent) were enrolled in a technical high school or an agriculture                               2011         983            -0.4%
science program. There were four 9th grade students (1.8 percent)                                 2012         937            -4.7%
enrolled in an area magnet school and three in another public school.                             2013         900            -3.9%
There were also four students home-schooled (1.8 percent).                                        2014         886            -1.6%
                                                                                                  2015         850            -4.1%
Table 6 and Figure 8 present enrollment at the Bacon Academy.                                     2016         820            -3.5%
                                                                                                  2017         811            -1.1%
Grade-by-grade enrollment may be found in Appendix B. Enrollment                                                                    fell
                                                                                                  2018         776            -4.3%
from 987 students in 2010 to 743 students in 2020. This decline came                              2019         784             1.0%
after a 25-year period of enrollment growth that ended in 2009.                                   2020       743           -5.2%
Between 2010 and 2020, grade 9-12 enrollment decreased by 244                                     2021       702           -5.5%
students or 24.7 percent. I project that statewide public-school                                  2022         669            -4.7%
enrollment in grades 9-12 will have fallen 5.9 percent in that ten-year                           2023         640            -4.3%
period.                                                                                           2024         617            -3.6%
                                                                                                  2025         596            -3.4%
I expect that next year's enrollment at Bacon Academy will be 40                                  2026         591            -0.8%
students less than this year. I expect enrollment will fall below 700                             2027         558            -5.6%
                                                                                                  2028         561             0.5%
students in 2022. I anticipate an enrollment low of 560 students in
                                                                                                  2029         574             2.3%
2027 before a slight rebound to about 600 students at the projection’s                            2030       597           4.0%
end. The 2030 count would be about 145 students, 20 percent, below                                     the
October 2020 count. Statewide, I have projected an 8.7 percent decline in public school grade 9-12
enrollment between 2020 and 2030. I believe enrollment at the high school could average about 610 students
over the next ten years compared to the average of 849 students observed over the past ten years.



                                        Figure 8. Bacon Academy Enrollment

                   1200

                   1000 987 983 937
                                      900 886
                                                850 820
                                                          811
                   800                                          776 784 743
      Enrollment




                                                                              702 669
                                                                                        640 617
                                                                                                  596 591                 597
                   600                                                                                      558 561 574


                   400

                   200

                   0
                          10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
                                                                 October of Year
                                                                Actual Projected



                                                                   12
Factors Affecting the Projection

The primary reasons for elementary enrollment change lie in the births, the yield from the birth cohort and
grade-to-grade migration. Figure 9 presents the actual and provisional births from 1980 to 2019¸ and
estimated births from 2020 to 2025. Births ranged from a high of 245 in 1990 to a low of 111 in 2013. There
were 144 births recorded in 2017. That is the latest official count. The provisional counts are 135 births in
2018 and 159 births in 2019. From in-state births through September, I estimate there will be 138 births in
calendar year 2020. From 2000 to 2009, there was an average of 186 births annually. In the five years from
2011 to 2015, this fall’s kindergarten through 4th graders, births averaged 130. Births in the 2016 through
2020 period will average close to 147. The projection in years 2026 to 2030 assumes an average of 146 births
annually between 2021 and 2025. This was based on the Connecticut State Data Center’s 2017 projection of
Colchester women of child-bearing ages and my estimate of 2018 fertility in Colchester.



                                         Figure 9. Births Since 1980
                                  2
                                  4
                        250       5


                        200                                                      1
                                                                                 5
     Number of Births




                                                                                 9               Actual
                        150                                            1                         Projected
                                                                       1
                                                                       1
                        100


                        50


                        0
                            80
                            82
                            84
                            86
                            88
                            90
                            92
                            94
                            96
                            98
                            00
                            02
                            04
                            06
                            08
                            10
                            12
                            14
                            16
                            18
                            20
                            22
                            24



                                               Calendar Year




Figure 10 depicts the kindergarten yield five and six years after the birth year from 2005 to 2015 for
Colchester residents attending                        Figure 10. Kindergarten Yield From Birth
kindergarten in the Colchester Public                                     Cohort
Schools. The dark blue indicates the birth       140%
cohorts affected by full-day kindergarten,                        113.6                        116.2 115.8
                                                                                                           111.5
which started in 2013. There were 133            120% 100.5 101.8 % 104.2 99.4            106.4 %     %
                                                                                                            %
                                                                        %       94.0 91.4  %
births in 2014 and 158 children enrolled                 %    %             %
                                                 100%                            %    %
in Colchester kindergarten at age five in
2019 and an additional 17 who first              80%
                                                  Yield




enrolled in kindergarten at age six in           60%
2020. That was a yield of 116 percent.
The yield from the birth cohort ranged           40%
from a low 91 percent in 2011 to a high          20%
of 116 percent in 2013 and 2014. The
estimated yield in 2015 was 112 percent.         0%
                                                         05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15
That yield is an estimate because we will                                    Birth Year
not know the number of students that will

                                                          13
first enter as six-year olds until October, 2021. Yields above 100 percent generally mean that parents
who give birth elsewhere move into town before their child enters kindergarten. In the four-year pre-
Covid-19 look-back period of the projection, the yield was 108 percent.

Table 7 gives a history of enrollment in kindergarten since 2010 and relates the components of kindergarten
enrollment back to the appropriate birth cohort. Retention is tied to the prior year's kindergarten enrollment.
With births returning to more normal levels, I estimated kindergarten enrollment using the four-year average
(2016-2019) growth of retentions, and yields from births five and six years ago. Thus, I estimated
kindergarten from 95.2 percent of births five years ago, 11.3 percent of births six years ago, and 4.1 percent of
current kindergarten students retained.


 Table 7. Analysis of Kindergarten Enrollment
                                                                                                Yield     Yield     Total
                                Retained      - - - - Non-Retained - - - -                     From      From       Yield
                                   From    Born 5-Years Prior                Born              Births    Births     From
                                           Colcheste
        Birth                      Prior           r      Non-         6 Years      Percent   5-Years   6-Years     Birth
                 Birth                                                              Retaine
 Year    Year      s       K       Year     Resident     Resident        Prior            d     Prior     Prior   Cohort

 201                       20
 0      2005     190        2         5         172              0            25      2.1%    90.5%     12.0%     100.5%
 201                       18
 1      2006     169        0         6         155              0            19      3.0%    91.7%     10.0%     101.8%
 201                       17
 2      2007     147        0         5         148              0            17      2.8%    100.7%    10.1%     113.6%
 201                       15
 3      2008     144        8         6         133              0            19      3.5%    92.4%     12.9%     104.2%
 201                       16
 4      2009     164        2         2         143              0            17      1.3%    87.2%     11.8%      99.4%
 201                       14
 5      2010     151        7         1         125              0            20      0.6%    82.8%     12.2%      94.0%
 201                       13
 6      2011     139        8         8         113              0            17      5.4%    81.3%     11.3%      91.4%
 201                       15
 7      2012     140        5         7         134              0            14      5.1%    95.7%     10.1%     106.4%
 201                       12
 8      2013     111        7         2         114              0            15      1.3%    102.7%    10.7%     116.2%
 201                       15
 9      2014     133        8         6         137              0            15      4.7%    103.0%    13.5%     115.8%
 202                       14
 0      2015     127        7         4         126              0            17      2.5%    99.2%     12.8%     111.5%

 3-Year Average                                                                      2.7%     101.6%    12.2%     114.5%
 Weighted 3-Year Average                                                             3.1%     101.1%    12.7%     113.7%
 5-Year Average                                                                      3.7%      96.0%    11.6%     108.3%
 Weighted 5-Yr Average                                                               3.4%      99.3%    12.1%     111.6%
 2016-2019                                                                           4.1%      95.2%    11.3%     107.5%

The correlation between births and kindergarten enrollment five-year later was a high 0.94 over the 1995
to 2020 period. If this relationship were used to predict kindergarten enrollment, the estimate would have
been off by an average of eight children annually over the past ten years. The cohort survival method,
even with my breakout into five-year olds, six-year old delayed entrants and children retained, cannot
overcome the underlying unpredictability of kindergarten enrollment from earlier births.


                                                       14
In the four-year look-back period of the kindergarten projection, births ranged from 111 to 140. Future
kindergarten classes will be based on 135-159 births. That is somewhat above the range in the look-back
period. We have to trust that the growth rate from birth to kindergarten will not change when births
increase. If it does, future kindergarten enrollment could be over-estimated.

The “Connecticut Early Childhood Report on Changing the Kindergarten Date,” mandated by Public Act
14-39, recommended that the start date for kindergarten be moved back to October 1st phased in one
month increments over the course of three years. It further recommended the elimination of the section of
C.G.S Sec. 10-184 which allows parents the option of not enrolling their age-eligible child. Funds for the
implementation have not yet been made available by the General Assembly. Unless the state’s fiscal
situation changes for the better or a court intervenes, I do not believe this common-sense change will be
implemented. Once implemented, the changes will very slightly decrease the size of your kindergarten
class for three years and increase your pre-kindergarten enrollment. This change is not built into this
projection, but will be built into future projections once the implementation date is set.

Figure 11 gives a perspective of the grade-to-grade growth rates for resident students attending the
Colchester schools. An "x" indicates the average growth rate used in this projection. The diamond is the
growth observed between last year and this year. The upper line indicates the largest growth rate
observed over the past ten years and the lower line, the lowest. For example, in grade 2 the projection
used a growth multiplier of 1.034 over the prior year’s 1st grade enrollment. The rate between 2019 and
2020 was 1.016. Over the past ten years, the rate ranged from a low of 0.976 to a high of 1.078. In
general, the narrower the gap between the two lines is, the greater the accuracy of the projection. The
growth rates used in the projection were based on a three-year average of the observed grade-to-grade
growth.
                          Figure 11. Grade to Grade Growth Rates
Most model growth rates were in the middle to the upper end of the ten-year range. Grades 10 and 11
were the exceptions.
                1.10 Most model growth rates were close to the 2020 rates. The 2020 rates were well
below the projection growth rates in grades 2, 3 and 5. The 2020 rates set ten-year lows in grades 1, 5, 7,
10 and 12; they1.05
                 set a 10-year high in grade 6 only. Six of the eight elementary growth rates are above
                                                                                          2020
1.000, indicating that children are moving into the Colchester schools. The model growthHighrates in grades
2-12 averaged 0.989. That was essentially the same as last year’s projection. The comparable
                                                                                          Low rate for
2020 was 0.965.1.00The 20-year median of those annual grade-to-grade rates was 0.995      Projection
        Rate




               0.95

               0.90

               0.85

               0.80
                      1     2    3     4     5    6        7   8   9   10   11    12

                                           Grade Moving Into




                                                      15
Context of the Projection

The cohort-survival method typically needs only births and a few years of recent enrollment data to
generate a projection. Mathematically, nothing else matters. But enrollment changes do not occur in a
vacuum. Events and policies in the district, community and region all have some bearing on enrollment.
Remember that a basic assumption of the cohort-survival method is that the recent past can be a good
predictor of the near future. It is incumbent for every receiver of a projection to determine what events
happened in the past few years and whether they are likely to change.

To assist in this endeavor, this report examines several factors that could affect enrollment: town
population; women of child-bearing age; the labor force; new home construction; sales of existing homes;
high school dropout rate; non-public enrollment; non-resident enrollment in Colchester schools; resident
enrollment in other public schools and student migration.

                                                                     Figure 12. Estimated Population Growth,
                                                                                   2010 to 2019 -3.23%  -0.31%
                                                                              -1.19%      -0.39%
                                                                     0.0%

                                                 Estimated Growth
                                                                     -0.5%
                                                                     -1.0%
                                                                     -1.5%
                                                                     -2.0%
                                                                     -2.5%
                                                                     -3.0%
                                                                     -3.5%
                                                                             Colchester   State     New     DRG D
                                                                                                   London
                                                                                                    Cnty

Figure 12 presents the US Census Bureau          and 2025. They also projected the population ages 5-9
estimate of Colchester population growth         would fall from 824 in 2020 to 790 (-4.1 percent) in
between 2010 and 2019. The estimate is           2025. They projected that number of children ages 10-
based, in part, on relative housing growth       14 would decline sharply from 1,011 in 2020 to 876 (-
within New London County. In that period,        13.4 percent) in 2025. The number of youth ages 15-19
the population is estimated to have declined     was projected to decline from 1,136 in 2020 to 915 in
by 191 people. Colchester’s population loss      2025 (-19.5 percent). This independent projection
of 1.2 percent ranked it 79th in the state. In   forecasts a steeper decline than the projection in this
contrast, New London County fell by 3.2          report.
percent, the state fell by 0.4 percent and
communities with similar economic and
need characteristics (DRG D) fell by 0.3
percent.




Figure 13 presents the Connecticut State
Data Center’s 2017 population projections
for Colchester residents 0-19 years of age
in the years 2015, 2020 and 2025. They
projected that the population ages 0-4
would increase 9.3 percent between 2020
                                                                    16
                            Figure 13. Projected Colchester
                                 Population Ages 0-19
                     1400
Number of Children




                     1200
                     1000                                     2015
                                                              2020
                     800
                                                              2025
                     600
                     400
                     200
                     0
                              0-4     5-9    10-14   15-19
                                      Age Group




                                                                17
Figure 14 presents the Connecticut State                              Figure 14. Colchester Women of Child-
Data Center’s 2017 projections of the                                              Bearing Age
number of women of child-bearing age in                               700
Colchester from 2015 to 2025. The Center
                                                                      600




                                                Number of Women
projected a 3.6 percent decline in the
                                                                                                                             2015
number of Colchester women ages 15-44                                 500
                                                                                                                             2020
between 2020 and 2025. However, in                                    400                                                    2025
communities like yours, 30-34-year-old
                                                                      300
women have the highest rate of births. The
Center projected that the number of women                             200
in that group would grow from 443 in 2020                             100
to 464 (+9.2 percent) in 2025. The second                             0
highest birth rate in communities like                                      15 to 20 to 25 to 30 to 35 to 40 to 45 to
Colchester is women ages 25-29. The                                          19 24 29 34 39 44 49
Center projected that the number in that age                                                Age Group
range would grow from 434 in 2020 to 464
(+6.9 percent) in 2020.

Figure 15 examines the number of people
in the labor market from the US                                       Figure 15. Recent Changes in the Labor
Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor                                                  Force
Statistics. These are people 16 years of age
or older who were working or actively were                        10000 94499491 9368 9248 93949381940494099429 9526
seeking employment. The Colchester labor
                                                                  8000
force decreased between 2010 and 2013
                                                Number




and then rebounded. Between 2010 and                              6000
2019, the net increase was 0.81 percent.
This was better than the state (+0.1 percent)                     4000
and New London County (-4.5 percent).
Colchester’s 2019 unemployment rate of                            2000
3.1 percent was down 4.8 percentage points                        0
from the 2010 high. It is better than the                                    10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19
state rate of 3.7 percent and the New
                                                                                                Calendar Year
London County rate of 3.6 percent. Covid-
19 brought Colchester’s July
unemployment rate up to 7.7 percent.

Figure 16 presents the net new housing                                     Figure 16. Net New Housing Units
permits issued from 2009 to 2019 from the
State Department of Economic and
                                                                      70
Community Development. In the past ten                                                                      63
years the number of net (of demolitions)                              60
new housing permits issued in Colchester                              50
                                                   New Units




ranged from a low of 18 in 2011 to a high                             40
of 63 in 2016. There were 12 permits                                             33                              34
                                                                                                 29 28 30               31
issued in 2019. In the four-year look-back                            30                   25
                                                                            21
period for this projection, there was an                              20              18
                                                                                                                              12
average of 19 net new housing permits                                 10
issued.
                                                                      0
                                                                            09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19
                                                                                           Calendar Year



                                                        18
                                                                          Figure 17. Sales of Existing Single-Family
                                                                                 Homes and Condominiums
                                                                          250
                                                                                                           204               199 193
                                                                          200                                          183             186
                                                                                                                 153
                                                                          150




                                                               Sales
                                                                                115 121        106
                                                                                                     117
                                                                          100             80

                                                                          50

                                                                          0
                                                                                09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19
                                                                                           Calendar Year

Figure 17 presents my estimate of the            students from the town of Colchester. The data are from
number of sales of existing single-family        the records of the Connecticut State Department of
homes and condominiums. I derived it by          Education.
                                                         FigureNon-public
                                                                  18. Annualenrollment
                                                                               High Schoolranged   from a high
                                                                                                 Dropout
taking the number of real estate transactions    of 161 students in 2010 toRatea low of 69 students in 2019,
from The Warren Group/Commercial                 the latest data available. In the past ten years,         1.15
Record and subtracting the number of new               1.2% in the non-public schools declined by 78%
                                                 enrollment
                                                  Percentage Drop-Outs


single-family housing units authorized the       students
                                                       1.0%
                                                           or 0.90
                                                              53 percent. The 2019 non-public enrollment
prior year. The estimated number of sales        represented % 2.8 percent0.75
                                                                            of all students from
                                                                                               0.73 Colchester.
of existing homes ranged from a low of 80              0.8% ago, 0.61
                                                 Ten years             0.61 %
                                                                   the figure was  4.3  percent.% I project that
                                                                                     0.56 0.59
in 2011 to a high of 204 in 2014. There          non-public
                                                       0.6% enrollment from0.44
                                                                    %   %        Colchester
                                                                                      % % will be about 75
were 186 sales of existing homes in 2019.        students in 2020.              %
In the four-year look-back period of the                                 0.4%
projection, there was an average of 190                                                                                  0.12 0.13
                                                                         0.2%                                             % %
sales annually. Sales through September
are on track to approach 205 in 2020.                                    0.0%
                                                                                10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
Figure 18 shows the annual percentage of
                                                                                          School Year Ending June 30
dropouts from grades 9-12 for the 2009-10
to 2019-20 school years. The data were
provided by the Connecticut State
Department of Education and the
Colchester central office. Dropouts are                                  Figure 19. Non-Public School Enrollment
students who left school early, left to enroll
in a GED program, transfer to post-                                      180
                                                                                 161
secondary education prior to graduation or                               160
                                                                             147     141
moved but not known to be continuing.                                    140             131
                                                                                             124      118
The high school dropout rate ranged from a                               120                     111
                                                      Enrollment




low of 0.12 percent in 2017-18 to a high of                              100                              98 103
1.1 percent in the 2019-2020 school year.                                80
                                                                                                                 81
Over the four years between 2016 and                                                                                69
                                                                         60
2019, the average rate was 0.4 percent. The
                                                                         40
2020 rate was students who stopped
attending on-line instruction and had not                                20
logged in by October 1, 2020.                                            0
                                                                             09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19
                                                                                         October of School Year
Figure 19 presents the non-public
enrollment over the past ten years for

                                                                19
                                                                              Figure 20. Residents Enrolled in Other
                                                                                          Public Schools

                                                                         200

                                                                         150




                                                Residents
                                                                         100

                                                                         50
                                                                                         55
                                                                                    30
                                                                         0
                                                                                10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
                                                                                     Magnet   Tech+Ag     Other
                                                                                          October of Year


Figure 20 presents the enrollment of           Figure 22 presents the estimated migration of students
Colchester residents in other public schools   from Colchester. The rate is adjusted for Colchester
in Connecticut from 2010 to 2020. The          residents attending other public schools and non-
2020 data are preliminary. The number          residentsFigure
                                                         in Colchester schools.
                                                               21. Tuition       The figures
                                                                            Students          do not take
                                                                                       Attending
educated out-of-district rose from 95 in       into account home-schooled    children or students
                                                                   Bacon Academy
2010 to 198 in 2016 and then fell to 134 in    attending non-public schools. Estimated migration
2020. The number enrolled in magnet or         ranged30from a low of -3.2 percent in 2020 to a high of
charter schools rose from 30 students in       +1.0 percent in 2016. The data behind these      26 25may
                                                                                            25figures
2010 to 118 in 2016 and then fell to 42 in           25 in Appendices A and B. In the four-year 2016-
                                               be found
                                                                                        20there was an
                                                Enrollment




2019. In 2020, 42 students attended a          2019 look-back
                                                     20         period of the projection,
magnet or charter school, nine attended the    average migration of -0.06 percent. This four-year rate
agriculture science program at Lyman                 15 15 times in the past 33 years. The median
                                               was lower
Memorial High, 51 attended a State             over the
                                                     10 past 25 years was +0.34 percent
                                                                                    8
Technical High School, and 32 attended a
                                                                         5
special education program run by a RESC                                                  1    1   1
or another public-school district.                                       0
                                                                                10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
                                                                                          October of Year
Figure 21 presents the number of Norwich
residents who attended Bacon Academy on
a tuition basis. The option started with
eight students enrolled in 2016. The                                           Figure 22. Estimated Student Migration
number grew to 26 in 2019 and was 25 in
2020. These students represented 3.4
                                                                             1.5%                       0.9
percent of the Bacon Academy enrollment                                                     0.4         6%
                                                                                   -1.2
in 2020. The projection assumes nine                                         1.0%       0.1 5% -0.3 0.2     0.2    0.3
                                                   Estimated Migration




                                                                                                                       -3.1
Norwich residents will enroll in Colchester                                  0.5% 7% 5%         0%  6%      7%-1.7 0% 9%
                                                                                                                7%
grade 9 annually. Over the next ten years,                                   0.0%
                                                                             -0.5% 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
these tuition students from Norwich are
                                                                             -1.0%
projected to average 4.9 percent of Bacon                                    -1.5%
Academy enrollment.                                                          -2.0%
                                                                             -2.5%
                                                                             -3.0%
                                                                             -3.5%

                                                                                                  October of Year



                                                       20
Prior Projections of Enrollment

The cohort-survival projection method works by moving forward the pattern of recent events that are subsumed
within the grade-by-grade enrollment. This works very well when communities are stable. One way to know if
that assumption is valid is to examine how past projections have fared. Figure 24 presents the enrollment
projections that I have run for Colchester since 2008. Last year’s projection over-estimated 2020 enrollment by
81 students or 3.7 percent. The three enrollment projections that I did between 2008 and 2018 had one-year
error rates that averaged 1.7 percent. The one projection done between 2008 and 2015 had a five-year error rate
of 5.9 percent, which is 1.2 percent annualized.

Last year’s projection is running 3.7 percent high. In that analysis, I projected that K-2 enrollment would be
557 students in 2020. The actual enrollment of 506 was 51 students less than projected. The projection was
high by 10.1 percent. I projected that enrollment in grades 3-5 would be 458 students in 2020. The actual
enrollment of 443 was 15 students less than projected. The projection was high by 3.4 percent. I projected that
this year’s enrollment at William J. Johnson Middle School would be 507 students. The actual enrollment of
504 was three students less than projected. The projection was high by 0.6 percent. I projected that this fall’s
high school enrollment would be 755 students. The actual enrollment of 743 was 12 students less than
projected. The projection was high by 1.6 percent. The 2019 projection expected a pre-kindergarten enrollment
of 113 children. There were only 86 enrolled in 2020. The Covid-19 affected 2020 enrollment
disproportionately impacted younger students. This is similar to what I have observed so far this year in other
districts.


                                          Figure 23. Prior Projections of Enrollment

                       3500

                                                                                                        Actual
                                                                                                        2008
          Enrollment




                       3000
                                                                                                        2017
                                                                                                        2018
                                                                                                        2019
                       2500                                                                             2020



                       2000



                       1500
                              07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
                                                         October of Year




Over the past forty years, I have found the cohort-survival method provides estimates that are sufficiently
accurate for intermediate-range policy planning. The eight-year planning horizon for school construction grants
is at the limit of the useful accuracy of the method. The method usually does not attempt to predict the future.
Its key assumption is that the near future will be like the recent past. For example, projections done in the late
2000s did not anticipate the recession of 2010. Some policy changes such as kindergarten retention, drop-out
prevention programs and the number of credits to be considered a 10th grader can be built into a new projection.
It is incumbent upon the receiver of a projection to identify planned changes so that they can be built into a
projection.
                                                                 21
Summary

I project that total enrollment in 2030 will be essentially the same as 2020, right around 2,200 students. I project
that Colchester Elementary School enrollment could move upward from 506 students in 2020 to about 605
students in 2030. This would be about a 100-student gain, a growth of over 19 percent. I expect the Jack
Jackter School enrollment will increase from 443 students in 2020 to about 495 students in 2030. I believe that
future enrollment at the William J. Johnson Middle School could decline to about 430 students in 2020 and then
return to the October 1, 2020 count of 504 students in 2030. The peak enrollment at Bacon Academy was 1,003
students in 2009. Between 2020 and 2030, enrollment at the Academy could fall from 743 students to about 600
students. That would represent a loss of about 145 students, a decline of just under 20 percent.

This report is projecting a slight increase in the lower grades and a decline in enrollment in the upper grades. It
is critical to remember that a projection is just a moving forward of recent trends. Is the forecast realistic? In
the five years from 2011 to 2015 (this fall’s kindergarten through 4th graders) births averaged 130. Births in the
2016 through 2020 period will average close to 147. My model assumes that births in 2021 to 2025 will average
146. I used a 7.5 percent growth between birth and eventual kindergarten enrollment. The median over the past
15 years was 4.2 percent. (That included years when full-day kindergarten was not offered.) The average of the
grade-to grade growth rates across grades 2-12 that I used to grow future enrollment was 0.989. That is about
the same as last year. These projection multipliers averaged a Covid-19 depressed 0.965 in 2020; the median
over the last 20 years was 0.995. Taking these three key factors into consideration, I believe the projection is
realistic.

These projections are based upon several other assumptions revolving around the notion that the recent past is a
good predictor of the near future. The projection assumes that the following school policies will continue:
kindergarten will remain full-day; 11 percent of parents will delay their child’s kindergarten entry until age 6;
nine Norwich children will enroll in grade 9 annually, retention policies will not change; no expansion of
enrollment in area magnets and no change in the dropout rate. The projection assumes a student migration of
-0.06 percent; a very slight decline in non-public school enrollment; 19 new housing units will be constructed
annually; an average of 190 sales of existing single-family homes and condominiums and a slight increase in the
labor force.

Obviously Covid-19 has introduced uncertainty into this projection. I assumed that the epidemic would be
substantially behind us by October of 2021. I assumed that the pattern of growth observed between 2016 and
2019 would return. I further assumed that the increase in students home-schooled would return over the next
two years. I further assumed that the job insecurity introduced by Covid-19 would depress births in 2021 and
2022. Those are a lot more assumptions than my typical projection. You also appear to have recently changed
the number of credits required to move from grade 9 to 10. This is not built into the high school’s projection. I
expect that grade 9 will be have slightly higher enrollment than projected and grade 10 slightly lower. A bit
more caution than usual must be exercised when using these projections to make policy decisions.

It is important to remember that the cohort survival method relies on observed data from the recent past. Its key
assumption is that those conditions will persist. It does not try to predict when the economic conditions might
change. We cannot know today how long these conditions will continue. This projection should be used as a
starting point for local planning. Examine the factors and assumptions underlying the method. You know your
community best. Apply your knowledge of the specific conditions in Colchester and then make adjustments as
necessary.




                                                        22
    Appendix A. Colchester Enrollment Projected by Grade to 2030: Primary and
    Intermediate Grades
               Birt
    School      h                                                                                        Total      Total
     Year      Year      Births1       K          1        2          3       4         5      PK        PK-2         3-5
    2010-11    2005       190         202       228      207        214     233       241       61        698        688
    2011-12    2006       169         180       197      223        204     214       236       80        680        654
    2012-13    2007       147         170       171      195        222     198       210       76        612        630
    2013-14    2008       144         158       164      170        196     220       198       59        551        614
    2014-15    2009       164         162       161      160        168     200       217       59        542        585
    2015-16    2010       151         147       171      161        163     165       203       91        570        531
    2016-17    2011       139         138       141      171        170     162       166       53        503        498
    2017-18    2012       140         155       144      152        174     170       169       92        543        513
    2018-19    2013       111         127       160      149        151     161       170       97        533        482
    2019-20    2014       133         158       128      165        142     154       160      104        555        456
    2020-21    2015       127         147       143      130        159     139       145       86        506        443
    Projecte
    d
    2021-222    2016       161        174       151      151        134     156       142       95        571        432
    2022-232    2017       144        162       176      157        154     133       158      100        595        445
    2023-24     2018       135        151       164      182        158     151       134      100        597        443
    2024-25     2019       159        173       153      170        183     155       153       95        591        491
    2025-26     2020       138        156       175      158        171     180       157       97        586        508
    2026-27     2021       142        157       158      181        159     168       182       99        595        509
    2027-28     2022       145        160       159      163        182     156       170      100        582        508
    2028-29     2023       146        162       162      164        164     179       158      101        589        501
    2029-30     2024       149        165       164      168        165     161       181      101        598        507
    2030-31     2025       150        166       167      170        169     162       163      101        604        494
    Projection Growth Rates3                 1.011     1.034     1.006    0.983     1.011    0.661

    Annual Resident Growth Rates
                                                                                                             Migration4
    2011                            1.065    0.975     0.978     0.986    1.000     1.013    0.550               0.15%
    2012                            1.156    0.950     0.990     0.996    0.971     0.981    0.494               0.45%
    2013                            1.097    0.965     0.994     1.005    0.991     1.000    0.375              -0.30%
    2014                            0.988    1.019     0.976     0.988    1.020     0.986    0.407               0.00%
    2015                            0.974    1.056     1.000     1.019    0.982     1.015    0.652               0.26%
    2016                            0.993    0.959     1.000     1.056    0.994     1.006    0.422               0.96%
    2017                            1.107    1.043     1.078     1.018    1.000     1.043    0.754               0.27%
    2018                            1.144    1.032     1.035     0.993    0.925     1.000    0.746              -1.77%
    2019                            1.188    1.008     1.031     0.953    1.020     0.994    0.722               0.30%
    2020                            1.157    0.905     1.016     0.964    0.979     0.942    0.564              -3.19%
    3-Year Ave.                     1.163    0.982     1.027     0.970    0.975     0.978    0.677
    Weighted 3-Year                 1.165    0.961     1.024     0.965    0.984     0.969    0.647
    5-Year Ave.                     1.118    0.990     1.032     0.997    0.984     0.997    0.642
    Weighted-5 year                 1.145    0.980     1.031     0.980    0.983     0.985    0.659
    2016-2019                       1.105    1.011     1.034     1.006    0.983     1.011    0.661
1
  2005-2019 births are from the State Department of Public Health. The 2018 and 2019 counts are provisional.
  The 2020 births were based on in-state births through September. Births in 2021-2025 were based on
  Connecticut State Data Center’s 2017 projection of Colchester women of child-bearing ages and my estimate of
  2018 fertility rates in Colchester.
2
  Enrollment in 2021 and 2022 assumes half of home-schooled students will return in 2021 and
  half of those remaining will return in 2022.
3
  Growth rates based on grade-to-grade rates between 2016 and 2019. Kindergarten based on four-year averages (2016-
2019) of estimated yield from births five- and six-years ago and retention.
4
  Estimated by comparing the enrollment in grades 3-8 one year with the enrollment in grades 2-7 the prior year with an
  adjustment for residents out and non-residents in.
                                                               23
    Appendix B. Colchester Enrollment Projected by Grade to 2030: Middle and High
    School Grades
                                                                                                          6-8       9-12           District
    School Year                  6         7          8          9         10        11         12      Total      Total             Total
    2010-11                    220       241        244        245        250       239        253       705         987             3,078
    2011-12                    234       224        242        228        247       249        259       700         983             3,017
    2012-13                    229       245        227        205        221       248        263       701         937             2,880
    2013-14                    197       230        241        205        208       224        263       668         900             2,733
    2014-15                    198       195        232        226        210       213        237       625         886             2,638
    2015-16                    213       198        189        202        219       204        225       600         850             2,551
    2016-17                    188       216        201        187        199       220        214       605         820             2,426
    2017-18                    165       193        213        203        185       197        226       571         811             2,438
    2018-19                    167       164        189        197        209       174        196       520         776             2,311
    2019-20                    174       170        173        207        194       196        187       517         784             2,312
    2020-21                    165       170        169        175        197       184        187       504         743             2,196

    Projected
    2021-223                   144       168        173        165        169       184        184        485         702            2,190
    2022-233                   140       147        170        168        159       158        184        457         669            2,166
    2023-24                    155       142        148        173        161       149        157        445         640            2,125
    2024-25                    131       157        143        152        166       150        149        431         617            2,130
    2025-26                    150       133        158        147        146       154        149        441         596            2,131
    2026-27                    154       152        134        161        141       136        153        440         591            2,135
    2027-28                    178       156        153        138        154       131        135        487         558            2,135
    2028-29                    167       180        157        156        132       143        130        504         561            2,155
    2029-30                    155       169        181        160        149       123        142        505         574            2,184
    2030-31                    177       157        170        183        153       139        122        504         597            2,199

    Projection
    Growth Rates            0.980      1.014      1.006     0.963      0.955      0.927      0.995
    Annual                                                                                                              Estimated
    Growth Rates1                                                                                                           Migration2
    2011                    0.971      1.018      1.004     0.934      1.008      0.996      1.084                               0.15%
    2012                    0.970      1.047      1.013     0.847      0.969      1.004      1.056                               0.45%
    2013                    0.938      1.004      0.984     0.903      1.015      1.014      1.060                              -0.30%
    2014                    1.000      0.990      1.009     0.938      1.024      1.024      1.058                               0.00%
    2015                    0.982      1.000      0.969     0.871      0.969      0.971      1.056                               0.26%
    2016                    0.926      1.014      1.015     0.952      0.950      0.973      1.015                               0.96%
    2017                    0.994      1.027      0.986     0.950      0.925      0.930      0.973                               0.27%
    2018                    0.988      0.994      0.979     0.887      0.990      0.897      0.954                              -1.77%
    2019                    1.024      1.018      1.055     1.063      0.954      0.909      1.040                               0.30%
    2020                    1.031      0.977      0.994     0.971      0.917      0.912      0.918                              -3.19%

    3-Year Average          1.014      0.996      1.009     0.974      0.954      0.906      0.971
    Weighted 3-Yr           1.021      0.993      1.012     0.988      0.942      0.909      0.965
    5-Year Average          0.993      1.006      1.006     0.965      0.948      0.924      0.980
    Weighted 5-Yr           1.009      1.000      1.008     0.975      0.945      0.915      0.972
    2016-2019               0.980      1.014      1.006     0.963      0.955      0.927      0.995
1
  Annual growth rates in grades 9-12 adjusted for tuition students from Norwich. The projection assumes
   9 Norwich residents will enroll in grade 9 annually.
2
  Estimated by comparing the enrollment in grades 3-8 one year with the enrollment in grades 2-7 the prior year with adjustments
  for residents out and non-residents in.
Grade 9 enrollments based upon three-year averages of the annual resident growth rates plus 9 students from

                                                                     24
Norwich in grade 9 in 2020 and 10 in 2021-29.




                                                25